Customer Service | Help | FAQ | Report a Data Error | About
Tip: To open articles without exiting the current webpage…

PEP-Web Tip of the Day

To open articles without exiting your current search or webpage, press Ctrl + Left Mouse Button while hovering over the desired link. It will open in a new Tab in your internet browser.

For the complete list of tips, see PEP-Web Tips on the PEP-Web support page.

Carveth, D.L. (2007). Self-Punishment as Guilt Evasion: The Case of Harry Guntrip. Canadian J. Psychoanal., 15:56-76.

Welcome to PEP Web!

Viewing the full text of this document requires a subscription to PEP Web.

If you are coming in from a university from a registered IP address or secure referral page you should not need to log in. Contact your university librarian in the event of problems.

If you have a personal subscription on your own account or through a Society or Institute please put your username and password in the box below. Any difficulties should be reported to your group administrator.


Can't remember your username and/or password? If you have forgotten your username and/or password please click here and log in to the PaDS database. Once there you need to fill in your email address (this must be the email address that PEP has on record for you) and click "Send." Your username and password will be sent to this email address within a few minutes. If this does not work for you please contact your group organizer.

OpenAthens or federation user? Login here.

Not already a subscriber? Order a subscription today.

(2007). Canadian Journal of Psychoanalysis, 15(1):56-76

Self-Punishment as Guilt Evasion: The Case of Harry Guntrip

Donald L. Carveth

A major contributor to the de-moralizing trend in post-Freudian and post-Kleinian psychoanalysis is Harry Guntrip. The guilt evasion that characterizes certain trends within contemporary psychoanalytic thought, and the contemporary culture to which they have adapted, mirrors that of Guntrip himself. Despite his background as a Christian minister and his years of analysis with two of the most creative analysts in the field, Guntrip managed by the end (in my hypothesis) only a paranoid understanding of himself as a victim of a murderous mother, rather than a man crippled by a need to punish himself for his disowned murderous wishes toward a brother who died and toward the mother he hated and blamed. In focusing upon the roots of the “schizoid problem” or the “disordered self” in defective early object-relations, Guntrip obscured entirely the role of guilt and the need for punishment in these conditions and promoted a cure based on reparative re-parenting rather than analysis and resolution of inner conflict.

Harry Guntrip a beaucoup alimenté la tendance de la psychanalyse postfreudienne et post-kleinienne à être « dé-moralisante ». L'évitement de la culpabilité qui caractérise certains courants de la pensée psychanalytique contemporaine et de la culture contemporaine à laquelle ces courants se sont adaptés reflète celui de Guntrip lui-mcme. Malgré son expérience de ministre


1 The present paper entails an application of the theory developed in “Self-Punishment as Guilt Evasion: Theoretical Issues” (this journal, 14(2], 175-196) in which I distinguish between the unconscious need for punishment driven by the punitive superego fuelled by aggression, and guilt as depressive anxiety or concern fuelled by attachment and love. Because the former frequently defends against the latter, the cure entails learning how to bear guilt such that its evasion through self-punishment is no longer necessary.

- 56 -

du culte chrétien et ses années d'analyse avec deux des analystes les plus créatifs de son temps, Guntrip, à la fin du processus (suivant mon hypothèse), ne se percevait que comme la victime d'une mère meurtrière, plutôt que comme un homme handicapé par le besoin de se punir de ses désirs meurtriers reniés à l'égard d'un frère que la mort avait emporté et d'une mère qu'il haïssait et croyait coupable. En se concentrant sur le « trouble schizoïde » ou le « soi désordonné » en ce qu'il plonge ses racines dans les relations objectales précoces déficientes, Guntrip a complètement occulté le rôle de la culpabilité et le besoin connexe de punition, et a préconisé une cure fondée sur la réparation par une nouvelle expérience de la parentalité plutôt que sur l'analyse et la résolution des conflits internes.

[This is a summary or excerpt from the full text of the book or article. The full text of the document is available to subscribers.]

Copyright © 2017, Psychoanalytic Electronic Publishing, ISSN 2472-6982 Customer Service | Help | FAQ | Download PEP Bibliography | Report a Data Error | About

WARNING! This text is printed for personal use. It is copyright to the journal in which it originally appeared. It is illegal to redistribute it in any form.