Tip: PEP-Web Archive subscribers can access past articles and books…
PEP-Web Tip of the Day
If you are a PEP-Web Archive subscriber, you have access to all journal articles and books, except for articles published within the last three years, with a few exceptions.
For the complete list of tips, see PEP-Web Tips on the PEP-Web support page.
Maldonado, J.L. (2004). Commentary 1. Int. J. Psycho-Anal., 85(6):1321-1325.
(2004). International Journal of Psycho-Analysis, 85(6):1321-1325
Jorge Luis Maldonado
Jacobs draws attention to character traits that are manifested in Mr B's communication: ‘Mr B is also subtly, and not so subtly, provocative and mocking, often making a caricature of analysis and analysts’. I think that the symptom of wearing women's undergarments, becoming exited and masturbating is related to these traits. When establishing a fictitious feminisation, both the masculinity of the father and the femininity of the mother are, by identification, caricatured. This is a manic defence which serves to alter the paternal and maternal identifications, and which makes them seem ridiculous.
Comments on the 1st session
My first impression is that the patient, as Jacobs points out, is trying to work through oedipal feelings in relation to other bonds which the analyst has. Jacobs puts forward two alternative hypotheses: competitive feelings with the female patient for the analyst's love and/or rivalry with the male analyst for the attractive woman who is ‘at his side’; this may have caused a regressive fantasy of being a woman. If I had been in the analyst's position, I maybe would have begun my investigation from the same starting point, exploring possible oedipal fantasies in the transference. But, shortly afterwards, I would have included a mutative interpretation(Strachey, 1934) taking the emphasis away from exciting the analyst and shifting this wish towards the parents. I would have investigated some factors from his life history which made him feel that he lacks a father and which determined the stagnation in the development of his sexuality.
[This is a summary or excerpt from the full text of the book or article. The full text of the document is available to subscribers.]