The Information icon (an i in a circle) will give you valuable information about PEP Web data and features. You can find it besides a PEP Web feature and the author’s name in every journal article. Simply move the mouse pointer over the icon and click on it for the information to appear.
For the complete list of tips, see PEP-Web Tips on the PEP-Web support page.
Wiedeman, G.H. (1972). Comments on the Structural Theory of Personality. Int. J. Psycho-Anal., 53:307-314.
(1972). International Journal of Psycho-Analysis, 53:307-314
Comments on the Structural Theory of Personality
George H. Wiedeman
At the present time, the structural theory is generally accepted by most analysts as the most comprehensive formulation concerning the psychic personality. However, if the structures id, ego and superego are conceived as 'more imagery than theory' (Waelder), the usefulness of these subdivisions may be limited and in need of reformulation and revision. It is maintained in this paper that the term 'structure' as applied to id, ego and superego imposes unnecessary limitations on psychoanalytic theory. Structure defined by its function (Hartmann) is a contradiction in terms. Freud's original topographical theory rested on the subdivision of the psychic personality into the systems Pcpt., Mnem., Ucs., Pcs. and Cs. When Freud subdivided the psychic personality into id, ego and superego, he used various terms to designate the new subdivisions: configuration, agency, province, realm, etc. (in the original German: Bildung, Instanz, Provinz, Reich). The terms structure and structural relations (Struktur, Strukturverhältnisse) were used by Freud less frequently in relation to id, ego and superego than the other terms mentioned above.
The term 'system' in relation to the topographical model was based on the usage of this term in the 19th century. If it were possible to apply the present scientific use of the term system to id, ego and superego, psychoanalytic theory would be better integrated into the mainstream of science, become more clearly understandable to workers in other scientific fields, and last but not least, benefit by achieving greater consistency and conceptual clarity than prevails at the present time. The subdivisions of the psychic personality, as any system or subsystem, can be characterized by boundaries, structures, functions and history, and can be correlated to the five metapsychological points of view.
[This is a summary or excerpt from the full text of the book or article. The full text of the document is available to subscribers.]