Tip: To see statistics of the Most Popular Journal Articles on PEP-Web…
PEP-Web Tip of the Day
Statistics of the Most Popular Journal Articles on PEP-Web can be reviewed at any time. Just click the “See full statistics” link located at the end of the Most Popular Journal Articles list in the PEP Section.
For the complete list of tips, see PEP-Web Tips on the PEP-Web support page.
Rahman, L. (1954). Oral Surgery, Oral Medicine, and Oral Pathology. V, 1952: Emotional Factors in Periodontal Disease. Ruth Moulton, Sol Ewen, and William Thieman. Pp. 833-860.. Psychoanal Q., 23:309-310.
Psychoanalytic Electronic Publishing: Oral Surgery, Oral Medicine, and Oral Pathology. V, 1952: Emotional Factors in Periodontal Disease. Ruth Moulton, Sol Ewen, and William Thieman. Pp. 833-860.
Workers in the field of periodontal disease now agree that breakdown in the mouth is the result of a complex of local and systemic factors, with no single
- 309 -
cause for all cases. In many cases, local mechanical and bacteriological treatment has been successful, but in others the disease persists or recurs in spite of all such efforts, and the role of emotional factors has come to be recognized. Vincent's infection is now regarded as not a communicable disease in the usual sense. It is felt that epidemics occur where many people live under the same conditions as, for example, in army life, where outbreaks follow excessive fatigue, stress, or anxiety.
Twenty-two cases were studied by a psychiatrist, a periodontist, and a dental consultant in a large clinic. Six had acute necrotizing gingivitis (Vincent's), and sixteen had chronic periodontitis. Oral dependency was the one outstanding pattern in all cases except one, the oldest and the only diabetic patient. Hostility was prominent in a number of the older patients; it apparently staved off the breakdown until a later age. Ten of the twenty-two cases showed a marked lack of parental care, due to death, desertion, or neglect; seven had been much babied at home; and five others gave a strong impression of immaturity. All showed pronounced oral habits. Nine were aware of increased bleeding of the gums with overt anxiety. Five women noted increased bleeding of the gums at the time of the menses; three others dated the onset of gingival bleeding to the menarche.
All six cases of Vincent's infection seemed clearly to have been precipitated by acute anxiety; the sudden outbreak came after days or weeks of gradually gathering impetus. The two youngest girls were away from home for the first time and were mobilizing their conflicts about needing mother and home. A boy was impotent in attempting intercourse with an older woman, and the acute necrotizing gingivitis appeared a few days later. He feared homosexuality and later became a paranoid schizophrenic. One woman developed Vincent's infection after illicit intercourse while her husband was hospitalized for an anxiety neurosis. She was very immature, and her goal had been to find a fatherly object. No local dental causes were evident in any of these cases.
In chronic periodontitis the conflicts were long standing. Most of the women were caught in unhappy marriages, and a new burden, such as the husband's losing his job or the birth of a new baby, slowly precipitated symptoms. They were too dependent on their husbands or mothers, and responded to any difficulty with anxiety and strain. This group characteristically showed many gastric symptoms, and many sucked their gums or ground their teeth at night.
In a few cases, psychotherapy was helpful in overcoming the dependency and thus producing lasting improvement in the condition of the gums. Most of the patients, however, wanted immediate, magical help, did not maintain clinic contact, and were not helped; in fact, inconsistent clinic attendance was typical of the recalcitrant cases with recurrent breakdowns.
Ten patients with periodontosis, a noninflammatory destruction of the periodontium believed to be a constitutional disease, were used as controls. These patients were notably not anxious, would not ordinarily be considered neurotic, and were relatively stable in their life adjustments. They showed an independence never seen in the other groups, and the predominance of oral habits was absent.
- 310 -
Rahman, L. (1954). Oral Surgery, Oral Medicine, and Oral Pathology. V, 1952. Psychoanal. Q., 23:309-310